Saturday, August 02, 2003

ESCAPIST FANTASY AND POSTMODERN TECHNIQUE

There has been a certain amount of debate about escapist versus non-escapist fantasy that I think would be better discussed in the context of escapist versus non-escapist fiction.

First, though, I think it's important to reaffirm a very basic concept: All fiction is fantasy, on one level. No matter how "realistic" the fiction, it contains some element either in a different context than it occurs in the real world or an element of the imagination brought in by the writer that has only a loose association with reality. To me, this seems like a rather safe and in some ways banal assumption.

In addition, however, I believe all fiction is fantasy because in one way or another fiction disappoints reality. No fiction can adequately describe even the interior of, say, a bookstore in such a way as to render it as real, on the level of specific detail, as you do when you visit said bookstore.

To some extent, then, all fiction is escapist, regardless of how grimly real. And in this sense, "escapist" means "untrue." Thus, fiction can either be more or less escapist--it cannot be other than escapist, because it is, on the face of it, false to reality in some way, no matter how minor or major that way might be...(My own fiction often deals with the failure or the success of the imagination to transcend reality, or to transform reality, which fits into this discussion in a way that requires its own mini-essay in future.)

If you accept my argument above, then postmodern technique, by insisting that the reader face the reality that all fiction is fantasy (suspension of disbelief overruled), is in a sense less escapist than purely modernist fiction. By the same measure, postmodern fiction containing a "fantasy" element (for fantasy element, read: an event or person that could not exist in the "real" world in any sense) or fantasy containing a postmodern element, is thus the least escapist of all types of Fantasy (here I use the term fantasy as a publisher would label-wise, just for the sake of the hypothetical).

How does this impact the current debates in the fantasy field. First, a China Mieville novel with a milieu in which Marxist or Socialist society may be the norm is no more or less escapist than J.R.R. Tolkien's fantasy of pastoral bliss threatened by industrialization. Ian R. MacLeod's The Light Ages, in which a socialist revolution fails, is also not any more or less escapist in the sense that, no postmodern technique being employed, the reader is still allowed to escape into the fiction of "suspending disbelief." And M. John Harrison's "forgiveness" of fantasy in his last short story collection by changing "A Young Man's Journey to Viriconium" to "A Young Man's Journey to London" does not in any sense change the escapist element or lack thereof, no matter how important that title change (and thus emphasis change) is to Harrison himself. (Whether he is describing London or an entry-point to the fantastic Viriconium, Harrison is still describing a place that exists only in his head.)

All of which is by way of actually saying--I don't know how useful it is to talk about escapist versus non-escapist fantasy. I am not claiming that postmodern fantasy is superior--just that the existence of postmodern fantasy allows for arguments like the above. Perhaps "escapist fantasy", or a degree of it, should not be dismissed so readily, considering that most everyone writing today is engaging in it. ;)

(This is a musing in progress, so no brickbats.)

Jeff



9 Comments:

At 9:28 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Interesting concept. I'm writing an essay on this topic, and stumbled on this blog. It's quite true. All fiction has to be to a certain degree, escapist. Simply because it is escapist does not mean it can't have deeper meaning, or a historical context.

 
At 8:17 AM, Blogger dharmabeatdown said...

I suppose this is the same continuum between opiates like laudanum where you are lulled into a pleasant dream, and maybe DMT, where you are smacked in the face with the knowledge of your own ultimate nonexistence.

Or dare I say perhaps like the continuum between an opiate like Christianity and something postmodern like Zen Buddhism? Sure, nothing's real, but let's examine exactly how we're experiencing it... :)

Call me crazy, but I always let resonances like these creep into my own fiction.

 
At 1:29 AM, Blogger Nikola said...

car insurance now its not what it used to be when we were kids

 
At 5:51 PM, Blogger داليا said...

http://www.prokr.net/2016/09/mosques-cleaning-companies-3.html
http://www.prokr.net/2016/09/mosques-cleaning-companies-2.html
http://www.prokr.net/2016/09/mosques-cleaning-companies.html

 
At 9:10 AM, Blogger حاتم النجار said...


شركة نقل عفش في القطيف

 
At 9:18 AM, Blogger حاتم النجار said...

تنظيف منازل بتبوك

 
At 11:22 PM, Blogger Unknown said...

adidas superstar
coach outlet online
canada goose outlet
michael kors outlet online
uggs outlet
moncler online
manolo blahnik
coach outlet
canada goose jackets
cheap jordans
uu0821

 
At 9:33 PM, Blogger yanmaneee said...

canada goose jacket
kobe 9
michael kors
adidas nmd r1
fila shoes
yeezy boost 350 v2
cheap jordans
hogan outlet
ferragamo belt
asics shoes

 
At 10:19 AM, Blogger yanmaneee said...

hermes belt
kawhi leonard shoes
golden goose
golden goose sneakers
supreme clothing
yeezy shoes
retro jordans
kobe byrant shoes
golden goose
bape clothing

 

Post a Comment

<< Home